You asked for $10 million and got $1 million instead. Here’s why that’s a win.

Lately, I’ve come across several nonprofit boards that are too focused on opportunity value and realized value—and the gap that exists between them.

Here’s what I mean.

Say you approach a prospective donor with a $10 million solicitation that ultimately ends with a $1 million gift. Some might see that as only 10% successful—or worse, a significant failure.

I’d argue that’s missing the point.

There’s a place for analyzing your asks versus your actuals. It can offer insights into the effectiveness of your donor strategy.

When you focus on the dollars that weren’t raised, however, you’re missing the importance of relationship building. 

Making a $10 million ask, even when you know it won’t yield that result, is a strategy. It tests ambition, interest, priorities, and readiness—for both you and the donor. An aspirational solicitation can raise the donor’s sights, inspiring them to think bigger about their giving and see themselves as a potential major philanthropist for your organization. 

Their response also informs your next steps in building the relationship. Just because the donor gives $1 million doesn’t mean they’ve closed the door on the remaining $9 million. That conversation may inspire a new level of engagement or create an opportunity for a deeper conversation. 

When you focus only on realized value and see a 10% success rate as a missed opportunity, you might unintentionally lower the bar for yourself. You might make smaller asks that you know you can land, but that don’t actually secure your organization’s vision. 

Sometimes we actually need to make those big asks, even when we only get 10% or 20% of what we were aiming for. People are rarely insulted by hearing you think they can give more than they can.

Plus, we’ve even seen donors be very taken aback by the size of a solicitation, only to come back a few days later with a commitment to give at that level. Some donors give far beyond anything they’ve considered simply because the ask was bold. 

At the Heller Fundraising Group, we encourage clients to go big. We want you to pursue your loftiest vision, test your most aspirational goals and reach higher than you’ve ever done before.

Sometimes that means taking a big swing even when you know you won’t get everything you ask for.

Megan Hodges

Consulting Services Director

From her early work broadening access to higher education at Princeton University to expanding opportunities for tens of thousands of low-income public school students through DREAM (formerly Harlem RBI) and Success Academy Charter Schools in New York City, Megan is motivated by the ability of individuals and organizations to translate mission and vision into measurable impact.

She has driven over $250 million in philanthropic support, built and led high-performing teams, and guided organizational expansion to new states and cities. Megan spent five years on the team providing overarching strategy and day-to-day oversight for Princeton University's $2 billion Aspire capital campaign and successfully led DREAM’s $25 million Level the Field capital campaign.

As Consulting Services Director, Megan manages client engagement as well as our exceptional team of collaborating consultants. She advises a broad range of clients on feasibility studies, capital campaigns, major gift fundraising, and strategies to drive organizational success.

Megan earned a B.S. in Media Theory and Communications from New York University. She is based in Richmond, VA, with her three dogs, enjoys cooking, and is always planning her next travel adventure (up next: Dublin).

Next
Next

Heller Group clients share how fundraising has reshaped their ideas of philanthropy